Melody's life is almost perfect. Graduate school, nursing, and now dating thanks to a good old-fashioned girlfriend's challenge. But what they don't know is Melody has already found the perfect man.

Miguel's the perfect neighbor. He checks the oil in Melody's car, hangs pictures on the walls, and handles the "Honey Do" List. But what he can't handle is another failed attempt at love, even though he thinks Melody is the perfect woman.

Two years as neighbors and friends is disrupted by a date (finally) gone right. Will Melody hold on to the dream that love is next door or move forward with a man willing and ready to give her forever?